Sir al-‘Alam al-Nabla ‘, vol. 4, p.134
Omar ibn al-Khattab has also changed the names of other people in history, of which we mention only three:
ย
1. Ibrahim ibn al-Harith with Abd al-Rahman
ุนุจุฏ ุงูุฑุญู
ู ุจู ุงูุญุงุฑุซ…. ูุงู ุฃุจูู ุณู
ุงู ุฅุจุฑุงููู
ูุบููุฑ ุนู
ุฑ ุงุณู
ู.
.His father named him Abraham; But Umar changed it and left Abdul Rahman
Al-isaba fi tamyiz Sahaba, vol. 5, p. 29
ุงูุนุณููุงูู ุงูุดุงูุนูุ ุฃุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุนูู ุจู ุญุฌุฑ ุฃุจู ุงููุถู (ู
ุชููุงู852ูู)ุย ุงูุฅุตุงุจุฉ ูู ุชู
ููุฒ ุงูุตุญุงุจุฉุ ุฌ 5ุ ุต 29ุ ุชุญููู: ุนูู ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุงูุจุฌุงููุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงูุฌูู – ุจูุฑูุชุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุฃูููุ 1412 – 1992.
ย
2.Al-Ajda ‘Abi Masruq with Abd al-Rahman
ุงูุฃุฌุฏุน ุจู ู
ุงูู ุจู ุฃู
ูุฉ ุงููู
ุฏุงูู ุงููุงุฏุนู… ูุณู
ุงู ุนู
ุฑ ุนุจุฏ ุงูุฑุญู
ู.
Omar ibn al-Khattab changed the name of Ajda ibn Malik to Abdul Rahman
Al-isaba fi tamyiz Sahaba, vol. 1, p. 186 , n:425
ุงูุนุณููุงูู ุงูุดุงูุนูุ ุฃุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุนูู ุจู ุญุฌุฑ ุฃุจู ุงููุถู (ู
ุชููุงู852ูู)ุย ุงูุฅุตุงุจุฉ ูู ุชู
ููุฒ ุงูุตุญุงุจุฉุย ุฌ 1ุ ุต 186ุ ุฑูู
: 425ุ ุชุญููู: ุนูู ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุงูุจุฌุงููุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงูุฌูู – ุจูุฑูุชุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุฃูููุ 1412 – 1992.
ย
3. Tha’albah ibn Sa’d by Moali
ููุงู ุฅุณู
ุงูู
ุนูู ุซุนูุจุฉุ ูุณู
ุงู ุนู
ุฑ ุจู ุงูุฎุทุงุจ ุงูู
ุนูู.
The original name of the Moali was Tha’lba, which changed its life and left a Moali
Al-Ansab, vol. 1, p. 250
ุงูุตุญุงุฑู ุงูุนูุชุจูุ ุฃุจู ุงูู
ูุฐุฑ ุณูู
ุฉ ุจู ู
ุณูู
ุจู ุฅุจุฑุงููู
(ู
ุชููุงู: 511ูู)ุย ุงูุฃูุณุงุจุ ุฌ 1ุ ุต 250.
ย
Ibn Hajar in his book Al-Asaba, chapter “Mentioning the name of Omar”
names twenty-one of the companions whose name were Omar:
ย
1. Omar ibn al-Hakam al-Salmi;
2. Omar ibn al-Hakam al-Bahzi;ย
3. Omar ibn Sa’d Abu Bakr al-Anmari;
4. Omar bin Saeed bin Malik;ย
5. Omar ibn Sufyan ibn Abd al-Asad;
6. Omar ibn Abu Muslim ibn Abd al-Asad;ย
7. Omar ibn Akramah ibn Abu Jahl;
8. Omar ibn Amr al-Lithi;
9. Omar ibn Umayr ibn Uday;ย
10. Omar ibn Umayr is not attributed;
11. Omar ibn Awf al-Nakha’i;ย
12. Omar ibn Lahaq;ย
13. Omar ibn Malik;ย
14. Omar ibn Mu’awiyah al-Ghazairi;ย
15. Omar ibn Wahb al-Thaqafi;ย
16. Omar bin Yazid Al-Kaabi;ย
17. Omar Al-Aslami;ย
18. Omar Al-Jami;ย
19. Omar Al-Khathami;
20. Omar Al-Imani. 21. Omar bin Al-Khattab.
ุงูุนุณููุงูู ุงูุดุงูุนูุ ุฃุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุนูู ุจู ุญุฌุฑ ุฃุจู ุงููุถู (ู
ุชููุงู852ูู)ุย ุงูุฅุตุงุจุฉ ูู ุชู
ููุฒ ุงูุตุญุงุจุฉุย ุฌ4ุ ุต587 ู 597ุ ุชุญููู: ุนูู ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุงูุจุฌุงููุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงูุฌูู – ุจูุฑูุชุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุฃูููุ 1412 – 1992.
Al-Ansab,ย vol. 4, pp. 587-597
Were these namings all due to their love to the second caliph?!
ย
Naming Othman:
Imam Ali (PBUH) naming his son Othman, was neither due to the similarity to the name ofย
the3rd Caliph, nor his interest in him. Rather, as the Imam (PBUH) said
he chose this name because of his interest in ‘Uthman ibn Maz’un’
ย
ุฅููู
ุง ุณู
ููุชู ุจุฅุณู
ุฃุฎู ุนุซู
ุงู ุจู ู
ุธุนูู
I named my son after my brother Uthman bin Mazoun
ุงูุงุตููุงููุ ุฃุจู ุงููุฑุฌ ุนูู ุจู ุงูุญุณูู (ู
ุชููุงู356)ุย ู
ูุงุชู ุงูุทุงูุจูููุ ุฌ 1ุ ุต 23.
Maqatil attalibin a,ย vol. 1, p.23
ย
Secondlyย
Ibn Hajar Asqalani mentions twenty-six companions whose names were Othman.ย
ย
Is it possible to say that all these names were beause of the third caliph whether before him or after him?
1. Othman bin Abu Jahm Al-Aslami;ย
2. Othman ibn Hakim ibn Abu al-‘Uqs;ย
3. Othman ibn Hamid ibn Zuhair ibn al-Harith;ย
4. Othman bin Hanif Balmahl;ย
5. Othman ibn Rabi’ah ibn Ahban;ย
6. Othman ibn Rabi’ah al-Thaqafi;
7. Othman bin Saeed bin Ahamar;ย
8. Othman ibn Shamas ibn al-Sharid;
9. Othman ibn Talhah ibn Abu Talha;ย
10. Othman ibn Abu al-‘As;ย
11. Othman ibn Amir ibn Amr;ย
12. Othman ibn Amir ibn Mu’tab;
13. Othman bin Abdul Ghanem;
14. Othman bin Obaidullah bin Othman;ย
15. Othman ibn Othman ibn al-Sharid;ย
16. Othman bin Othman Al-Thaqafi;ย
17. Othman ibn Amr ibn Rafi’a;
18. Othman bin Amr Al-Ansari;
19. Othman ibn Amr ibn al-Jumuh;ย
20. Othman ibn Qais ibn Abu al-‘As;ย
21. Othman bin Mazoun;
22. Othman ibn Mu’adh ibn Othman;ย
23. Othman bin Nofal Zam;
24. Othman bin Wahb Al-Makhzoumi;ย
25. Othman al-Jahani; 26. Othman bin Affan.
ุงูุนุณููุงููุ ุฃุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุนูู ุจู ุญุฌุฑ ุฃุจู ุงููุถู ุงูุดุงูุนูุย ุงูุฅุตุงุจุฉ ูู ุชู
ููุฒ ุงูุตุญุงุจุฉุ ุฌ 4ุ ุต 447 ู 463ุ ุชุญููู: ุนูู ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุงูุจุฌุงููุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงูุฌูู – ุจูุฑูุชุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุฃูููุ 1412 – 1992.
Al-isaba fi tamyiz Sahaba,ย vol. 4, pp. 447-463
ย
Detailed answers
1. No name (except the names of Allah the Almighty) is exclusive to one person; Rather, sometimes a name was chosen for many people who were known by the same name, and there were no restrictions on this among the tribes and nations; Therefore, names such as Abu Bakr, Omar and Othman have been common names that many people of the time of the Prophet and his companions and companions, as well as the companions, friends and companions of the Shiite Imams have been known by the same names, such as:
Abu Bakr Hadrami, Abu Bakr Ibn Abu Musaak, Abu Bakr Ayash and Abu Bakr Ibn Muhammad are the companions of Imam Baqir and Sadegh (PBUH). Omar ibn Abdullah Saghafi, Omar ibn Qays, Omar ibn Mu’ammar, one of the companions of Imam Baqir (PBUH). And Omar ibn Aban, Omar ibn Aban Kalbi, Omar ibn Abu Hafs, Omar ibn Abu Sa’ba! Omar ibn Azina, Omar ibn Bara, Omar ibn Hafs, Omar ibn Hanzala, Omar ibn Salma, etc. are among the companions of Imam Sadiq (PBUH).Othman Aami Basri, Othman Jabala and Othman Ibn Ziad are among the companions of Imam Baqir (PBUH), and Othman Asbahani, Othman Ibn Yazid, Othman Nawa, among the companions of Imam Sadegh (PBUH).
2. There is no doubt that the Shiites have had and still have a strong hatred of Yazid ibn Mu’awiyah and his ugly deeds; But at the same time, we see that among the Shiites and the companions of the Imams (PBUH) there were those whose name was Yazid; like:
Yazid ibn Hatim, one of the companions of Imam Sajjad (PBUH). Yazid ibn Abd al-Mulk, Yazid Saigh, Yazid Kanasi, one of the companions of Imam Baqir (PBUH); Yazid al-Sha’r, Yazid ibn Khalifa, Yazid ibn Khalil, Yazid ibn Omar ibn Talha, Yazid ibn Farqad, Yazid Molly Hakam from the companions of Imam Sadiq (PBUH).
Even one of the companions of Imam Sadegh (PBUH), his name was Shamar Ibn Yazid.
ุฅุจู ุจุทุงู ุงูุจูุฑู ุงููุฑุทุจูุ ุฃุจู ุงูุญุณู ุนูู ุจู ุฎูู ุจู ุนุจุฏ ุงูู
ูู (ู
ุชููุงู449ูู)ุย ุดุฑุญ ุตุญูุญ ุงูุจุฎุงุฑูุ ุฌ 9ุ ุต 344ุ ุชุญููู: ุฃุจู ุชู
ูู
ูุงุณุฑ ุจู ุฅุจุฑุงููู
ุ ูุงุดุฑ: ู
ูุชุจุฉ ุงูุฑุดุฏ – ุงูุณุนูุฏูุฉ / ุงูุฑูุงุถุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุซุงููุฉุ 1423ูู – 2003ู
.
Sharh Sahih Bukhari Vol.9,P.344
ย
Al-Ayni writes in ‘Umdatul Qari’
ููุงู ุนู
ุฑ ุฑุถู ุงููู ุชุนุงูู ุนูู ูุชุจ ุฅูู ุฃูู ุงููููุฉ ูุง ุชุณู
ูุง ุฃุญุฏุง ุจุงุณู
ูุจู ูุฃู
ุฑ ุฌู
ุงุนุฉ ุจุงูู
ุฏููุฉ ุจุชุบููุฑ ุฃุณู
ุงุก ุฃุจูุงุฆูู
ุงูู
ุณู
ูู ุจู
ุญู
ุฏ ุญุชู ุฐูุฑ ูู ุฌู
ุงุนุฉ ู
ู ุงูุตุญุงุจุฉ ุฃูู ุฃุฐู ููู
ูู ุฐูู ูุชุฑููู
.
ุงูุนูููุ ุจุฏุฑ ุงูุฏูู ู
ุญู
ูุฏ ุจู ุฃุญู
ุฏ (ู
ุชููุงู 855ูู)ุย ุนู
ุฏุฉ ุงููุงุฑู ุดุฑุญ ุตุญูุญ ุงูุจุฎุงุฑูุ ุฌ 15ุ ุต 39ุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุฅุญูุงุก ุงูุชุฑุงุซ ุงูุนุฑุจู – ุจูุฑูุช
ย
4. The name of one of the Companions is “Omar ibn Abu Muslim al-Qurashi” who was the adopted son of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) from Ummu Salma.ย
Howdo you certainly say that naming his son as Omar was not rather, due to the love to this adopted son of the Messenger of Allah?
ย
5. According to Sheikh Mofid, the name of one of the son of Imam Hassan (PBUH) was Amru.
Is it possible to say that this naming was due to the similarity to the name of Amr Ibn Abdud or Amr Ibn Hisham (Abu Jahl)?
Al-Irshad fi marifa hujaj Allah,Vol.2,P.20
ุงูุดูุฎ ุงูู
ููุฏุ ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุจู ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุงููุนู
ุงู ุงุจู ุงูู
ุนูู
ุฃุจู ุนุจุฏ ุงููู ุงูุนูุจุฑูุ ุงูุจุบุฏุงุฏู (ู
ุชููุงู413 ูู)ุย ุงูุฅุฑุดุงุฏ ูู ู
ุนุฑูุฉ ุญุฌุฌ ุงููู ุนูู ุงูุนุจุงุฏุ ุฌ 2ุ ุต 20ุ ุจุงุจ ุฐูุฑ ููุฏ ุงูุญุณู ุจู ุนูู ุนูููู
ุงย ุ ุชุญููู: ู
h9ู ุงูุจูุช ุนูููู
ุงูุณูุงู
ูุชุญููู ุงูุชุฑุงุซุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงูู
ููุฏ ููุทุจุงุนุฉ ูุงููุดุฑ ูุงูุชูุฒูุน – ุจูุฑูุช – ูุจูุงูุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุซุงููุฉุ 1414ูู – 1993 ู
.
6. According to what is stated in Sahih Muslim from the saying of Omar ibn al-Khattab, the opinion of Imam Ali (PBUH) towards Abu Bakr and Omar was that they were liars, sinners, deceivers and traitors, he addressed Ali (PBUH) and Abbas says:
ููููู
ููุง ุชูููููููู ุฑูุณูููู ุงูููููู -ุตูู ุงููู ุนููู ูุณูู
- ููุงูู ุฃูุจูู ุจูููุฑูย ุฃูููุงย ูููููููย ุฑูุณูููู ุงููููููย -ุตูู ุงููู ุนููู ูุณูู
- ููุฌูุฆูุชูู
ูุงย ุชูุทูููุจู ู
ููุฑูุงุซููู ู
ููู ุงุจููู ุฃูุฎูููู ููููุทูููุจู ููุฐูุง ู
ููุฑูุงุซู ุงู
ูุฑูุฃูุชููู ู
ููู ุฃูุจููููุง ููููุงูู ุฃูุจูู ุจูููุฑู ููุงูู ุฑูุณูููู ุงูููููู -ุตูู ุงููู ุนููู ูุณูู
- ยซ ู
ูุง ูููุฑูุซู ู
ูุง ุชูุฑูููููุง ุตูุฏูููุฉู ยป. ููุฑูุฃูููุชูู
ูุงูู ููุงุฐูุจูุง ุขุซูู
ูุง ุบูุงุฏูุฑูุง ุฎูุงุฆูููุง ููุงูููููู ููุนูููู
ู ุฅูููููู ููุตูุงุฏููู ุจูุงุฑูู ุฑูุงุดูุฏู ุชูุงุจูุนู ููููุญูููู ุซูู
ูู ุชูููููููู ุฃูุจูู ุจูููุฑูย ููุฃูููุงย ูููููููย ุฑูุณููููย ุงูููููู -ุตูู ุงููู ุนููู ูุณูู
-ย ูููููููููย ุฃูุจูู ุจูููุฑูย ููุฑูุฃูููุชูู
ูุงููู ููุงุฐูุจูุง ุขุซูู
ูุง ุบูุงุฏูุฑูุง ุฎูุงุฆูููุง.
After the death of the Messenger of God (may God bless him and grant him peace), Abu Bakr said: I am the successor of the Messenger of God.ย Abu Bakr said: The Messenger of God said: We do not inherit anything, what remains is charity andย youย introduced him as aย liar, a sinner, a deceiverย and a traitor, while God knows that Abu Bakr is truthful and religious. And he was a follower of the truth.ย After the death of Abu Bakr, I became the successor of the Prophet and Abu Bakr, and againย you twoย called meย a traitor, a deceitful liar, and a sinner
Sahih Muslim, vol. 3, p. 1378, p. 1757
ุงูููุณุงุจูุฑูุ ู
ุณูู
ุจู ุงูุญุฌุงุฌ ุฃุจู ุงูุญุณูู ุงููุดูุฑู (ู
ุชููุงู261ูู)ุย ุตุญูุญ ู
ุณูู
ุ ุฌ 3ุ ุต 1378ุ ุญ 1757ุย ููุชูุงุจ ุงููุฌูููุงุฏู ููุงูุณููููุฑูุ ุจูุงุจ ุญูููู
ู ุงููููููุกูุ ุชุญููู: ู
ุญู
ุฏ ูุคุงุฏ ุนุจุฏ ุงูุจุงููุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุฅุญูุงุก ุงูุชุฑุงุซ ุงูุนุฑุจู – ุจูุฑูุช.
“And in the narration that exists in Sahih Bukhari, Amir al-Mu’minin (PBUH) considers Abu Bakr as a “tyrant”
ย
ย
ููููููููููู ุงุณูุชูุจูุฏูุฏูุชู ุนูููููููุง ุจูุงููุฃูู
ูุฑู ูููููููุง ููุฑูู ููููุฑูุงุจูุชูููุง ู
ู ุฑุณูู ุงูููููู ุตูู ุงููู ุนููู ูุณูู
ููุตููุจูุง.
ย You overpowered us by force, and we deserved more to be in the caliphate because of our closeness to the Holy ย Prophet (PBUH)ย
Sahih al-Bukhari, vol. 4, p. 1549,
ุงูุจุฎุงุฑู ุงูุฌุนููุ ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุฅุณู
ุงุนูู ุฃุจู ุนุจุฏุงููู (ู
ุชููุงู256ูู)ุ ุตุญูุญ ุงูุจุฎุงุฑู ุฌ 4ุ ุต 1549ุ ุญ3998ุ ูุชุงุจ ุงูู
ุบุงุฒูุ ุจุงุจ ุบุฒูุฉ ุฎูุจุฑุย ุชุญููู: ุฏ. ู
ุตุทูู ุฏูุจ ุงูุจุบุงุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงุจู ูุซูุฑุ ุงููู
ุงู
ุฉ – ุจูุฑูุชุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุซุงูุซุฉุ 1407ูู – 1987ู
.
And in another narration, the Shaikhain (Abubakr and Omar) themselves have narrated that Imam Ali (PBUH) did not even like to see the face of Omar for a while:
ย
ููุฃูุฑูุณููู ุฅูู ุฃุจู ุจูููุฑู ุฃููู ุงุฆูุชูููุง ููุง ููุฃูุชูููุง ุฃูุญูุฏู ู
ูุนููู ููุฑูุงููููุฉู ููู
ูุญูุถูุฑู ุนูู
ูุฑู.
Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 4, p. 1549, H 3998
ุงูุจุฎุงุฑู ุงูุฌุนููุ ู
ุญู
ุฏ ุจู ุฅุณู
ุงุนูู ุฃุจู ุนุจุฏุงููู (ู
ุชููุงู256ูู)ุ ุตุญูุญ ุงูุจุฎุงุฑูุฌ 4ุ ุต 1549ุ ุญ3998ย ูุชุงุจ ุงูู
ุบุงุฒูุ ุจุงุจ ุบุฒูุฉ ุฎูุจุฑุย ุชุญููู: ุฏ. ู
ุตุทูู ุฏูุจ ุงูุจุบุงุ ูุงุดุฑ: ุฏุงุฑ ุงุจู ูุซูุฑุ ุงููู
ุงู
ุฉ – ุจูุฑูุชุ ุงูุทุจุนุฉ: ุงูุซุงูุซุฉุ 1407ูู – 1987ู
.
ย
With such sharp stances of Imam Ali (PBUH) against the caliphs, can it be claimed that he named his children after them because of his interest in the caliphs??!
7. Sunnis claim that these names were all chosen due to the good relationships of Imam Ali (PBUH) with the caliphs. If so, why did the caliphs not choose the names of Hassan and Hussein, who were also the children of the Messenger of God, peace be upon him, for their children?
ย
Can friendship be one-sided??!
ย
The names of the children of Imam Ali (PBUH) do not indicate a good relationship between him and the un-rightly Caliphs,ย and it cannot be used to deny the martyrdom of Lady Fatima, peace be upon Her.